User talk:Debarra

Nalthis

Hi there! Thanks for your hard work on the Nalthis page. It needed improvement, and we appreciate what you put into writing and citing everything. Unfortunately, the history section comes across as too detailed for the page. Generally on a Shardworld page we like to confine the history section to the "big picture" of events that occur on the planet. For instance, Threnody is a good example of the level of detail that's preferred. So all of that is to say, don't be too alarmed when you see it edited down. You could let some of the Keepers go through it, or if you prefer you can go through it yourself and get it to the point of being an overview of the planet's history. A lot of the content can be useful either in a culture section on the page (for the information regarding Returned in different nations, for example) or on other pages that are designed to handle more of the details. For instance, the Five Scholars article could use some of the content, as could Shashara and Hanald. If you'd like to discuss this further, you're welcome to reply here or the Nalthis talk page, or to join our Discord for Coppermind editors.
-- Truthwatch3r (talk) 02:27, 1 April 2022 (UTC)

Hey Truthwatch3r, thanks for getting in touch. Apologies if the page was too indepth, may have gotten carried away making it. I can go through it myself but unfortunately I have some exams coming up and those need to take priority right now so it may take a week or two before I can properly dive into revising the section. If this doesn't work though and people want to do it themselves in the mean time that's grand as well.

Apologies again for any mess I made.

-- Debarra (talk)

No need to apologize. Like I said, your work is very appreciated and will be useful in other places! We're happy to let you go through it yourself and totally understand that exams take priority. Good luck with them!

-- Truthwatch3r (talk) 14:24, 2 April 2022 (UTC)

Hey Truthwatch3r, went through them again and cut out most of the unneeded references. I've kept some details of the novel in the sections since I feel it would be weird to exclude them as the article felt incomplete without some details. If you want to look through the new version and revise is as needed that would be a help. Thanks again for your patience.

-- Debarra (talk)

Thank you very much! Yes I agree it definitely needs to include some of what goes on in the novel, as those are important parts of the world's history. I'll take a look at it sometime this week or the next. And thank you for taking the suggestion to pare it down gracefully!

-- Truthwatch3r (talk) 14:01, 8 May 2022 (UTC)

TLM Notes

Hey Debarra! Thanks for your work on all the new information from The Lost Metal! Just wanted to reach out to answer some questions/comments in some of your recent edits. The syntax for citing epilogues from the book is {{book ref|mb7|epilogue|#}} where # is the number of the epilogue. Also note that the names of God Metals, including trellium and harmonium/ettmetal, are not capitalized. With regard to trellium and "the final metal," as far as I can tell, it's never confirmed they are necessarily the same (and on a general note, I think it's probably better to double check the references before making a change like that). The only mentions of the final metal I can find are chapter 8, where Marasi thinks about Miles' last words and then touches the trellium spike she pulled from Granks, and chapter 60, where Marasi again thinks about Miles' last words after seeing the men of red and gold. Let me know if I'm missing a source though! Feel free to reach out if you have any other questions and happy editing!
--Stargazer (talk) 01:13, 17 November 2022 (UTC)

Hey Stargazer, thanks for reaching out. I fixed the epilogue reference there so it should be to the correct one. In future though may it be worthwhile to consider having a system where they aren't numbered for citations? In the UK at least none of them have numbers ascribed to them, perhaps it is different in the US edition? I'll go on to fix those capitalisations now as well.

As for the 'final metal' I'll have to double check myself in a bit, I could have sworn they explicitly stated it was the final metal at some stage throughout the novel but can't find it at the moment whilst flicking through my copy.--Debarra (talk) 01:23, 17 November 2022 (UTC)