Talk:Surgebinding

Difficulty

Surgebinding is hard, because we don't know much about it, and what we know is very much influenced by how the characters see it. I tried to be as general in my description as possible though. There are lots of things that seem to be taken for granted in relation to Surgebinding, f.ex. that one would always need an Honorspren, or that the bond between Surgebinder and spren is called Nahel Bond. I did not include those.

Dont worry dude, you did AWESOME :D You could probably add the things you marked as {t|clarify}} in under the {{theory}} banner. I reformatted the Order's section since each order should have its own page with more explanation. --Joe ST (talk) 22:05, 23 October 2012 (UTC)

Isomere's theory

Hey Isomere, I think we will be removing your theory, since it's so new. You yourself stated in the section that its premature. Until they have been accepted and critiqued by a number of people, I don't think it's worthy of a full section. I will leave it for now, until others have had input. --Joe ST (talk) 18:06, 23 April 2013 (UTC)

Oops, I didn't see this here; I had posted my response to you on your talk page, Isomere. I agree the theory is strongly premature. In fact I am uncomfortable with any theory on here that claims to know additional Surges, just as I would be uncomfortable with putting what people think could be Shards on the Shard page. Additionally, regarding Cultivation's relevance to Surgebinding, I'm... also uncomfortable with that claim. I am very certain that we can say that Surgebinding is of Honor, but I am uncomfortable displaying that it is of Cultivation as well without more concrete evidence. -- Chaos2651 (talk) 01:08, 24 April 2013 (UTC)