Difference between revisions of "User talk:Windrunner"
→Justice
Windrunner (talk | contribs) |
|||
|
: Because he <i>did</i> confirm that "Threnity" was feeling the effects of a dead Shardholder. -- [[User:199.27.133.204|Horatio Von Becker]]
::That's simply ''not'' the same thing as confirming a Shard named Justice. If I recall correctly, what Brandon did was state that the name Threnody is in some way related to the death of a Shard. Knowing Brandon, it easily could be true on a technicality. Nowhere did he say that that Shard is on Threnody, from Threnody, or that it is called Justice. Unless you've got additional evidence, it's not much more than baseless speculation.--[[User:Windrunner|Windrunner]] ([[User talk:Windrunner|talk]]) 09:34, 13 May 2016 (MDT)
:::Aside from Silence's mention that Justice died on Homeland? There were hints that Homeland was a different Shardworld, but the existence of the Simple Rules, and the Shades' role as their enforcers, does imply a relation to Justice. -Horatio Von Becker▼
::::I think you're confusing the role of the wiki. It is a place for facts and (very) occasionally theories that are all but confirmed and are supported by the majority of the community, book quotes, and Brandon's quotes. If you want to theorize about Justice as a potential Shard, feel free to do so on the forums, but the wiki is not going to have an article about it until there is far far more evidence than there is currently. That's just the way it is. --[[User:Windrunner|Windrunner]] ([[User talk:Windrunner|talk]]) 12:16, 13 May 2016 (MDT)▼
▲::Aside from Silence's mention that Justice died on Homeland? There were hints that Homeland was a different Shardworld, but the existence of the Simple Rules, and the Shades' role as their enforcers, does imply a relation to Justice. -Horatio Von Becker
:::::Ah. Curses. What's the general standard, then? Balance of evidence obviously isn't it, so I presume it's beyond reasonable doubt?
▲:::I think you're confusing the role of the wiki. It is a place for facts and (very) occasionally theories that are all but confirmed and are supported by the majority of the community, book quotes, and Brandon's quotes. If you want to theorize about Justice as a potential Shard, feel free to do so on the forums, but the wiki is not going to have an article about it until there is far far more evidence than there is currently. That's just the way it is. --[[User:Windrunner|Windrunner]] ([[User talk:Windrunner|talk]]) 12:16, 13 May 2016 (MDT)
| |||